Temperament Rating and military accolades. In the statistic that I presented in the earlier round, even if the amount of pitbull attacks was somehow skewed in favor of misidentifying pitbulls more often, that number could be reduced by more than two-thirds and still outweigh any other type of dog attack. Arguments against. The ASPCA says that,“guardians of banned breeds may be deterred from seeking routine veterinary care, which can lead to outbreaks of rabies and other diseases that endanger communities. Such laws range from outright bans on the possession of these dogs, to restrictions and conditions on ownership, and often establishes a legal presumption that such dogs are dangerous or vicious. But pit bulls are still barred from living on military bases, and hundreds of breed-specific bans remain in place. Breed-specific legislation refers to all laws that seek to restrict or eliminate ownership of certain animal breeds, most often dog breeds. Most dog owners would agree that pets are like family; each with their own personality, responses, and personal temperament, making them individuals. This debate has been configured to only allow voters who meet the requirements set by the debaters. For example, Peg Jordan, an Oakland, California resident, was recently mauled by a pit bull and spent several days in the hospital with more surgery to come. The police came in literally took the dog without a provocative in incident, had a trial killed the dog and never let the family in to see him. Italy, for example, repealed its breed-specific policies after six years of costly enforcement and ineffectiveness. Breed Specific Legislation (BSL) is a legalized form of animal discrimination which is sanctioned by local governments. Today, I would like to dig into the breed specific legislation debate, past and present. Breed-specific laws harm rather than improve public safety. True; a properly raised, trained, and contained Pit Bull is no danger to the public. Links to important articles and reports on Breed Specific Legislation (BSL) in the United States: Breed-Specific Legislation FAQ DogsBite.org, a national dog bite victims’ group dedicated to reducing serious dog attacks, releases a Breed-Specific Legislation FAQ on its website. No one has time to read them all, but it’s important to go over them at least briefly. This includes, beating, starving, baiting, feeding weird crap like gunpowder…. It’s National Pit Bull Awareness Month, a time to discuss Pit Bull type dogs and break down the myths and misconceptions that exist about the breed. National Canine Research Council This debate either has an Elo score requirement or is to be voted on by a select panel of judges. Luckily, FreeBookSummary offers study guides on over 1000 top books from students’ curricula! When the evidence supports that certain breeds of dogs present a public safety risk, it is within the government’s power to enact laws that will control the ownership of these breeds – whether through bans or restrictions. It is the government’s job to recognize that a specific type of animal poses a generalized risk and protect against that risk. The opponents argue that the legislation has acted erroneously with no adequate research to support the decision, as medical studies do not state breed as an influencing factor of viciousness. It is well within the purview of the government to protect its citizens through legislation. Legislators may be challenged to identify pit bull from photographs, and to listen to arguments intended to confuse the notion of “breed”. The amount of energy spent on trying to exterminate breeds of dogs is not only entirely out of proportion to their actual risk, but also a poor appropriation of time and energy that could be spent on the issue of real concern: irresponsible owners. The Fort Lauderdale community has become hotly concerned about the “intimidating pit bulls” on the beachfront which are “scaring ‘family’ tourists” away. Some of these individual animals might be safe, but as a whole they are not. You may present your opening argument in the next round. Posted on April 24, 2017 April 25, 2017 by alexb2448. This breed is more likely to have issues with other dogs than most other breeds and owners need to admit that and not set their dogs up to fail. These bodies prohibit the ownership of certain dogs just because they may look like a certain type of animal. What matters is that there is sufficient evidence for legislators to determine that pitbulls, rottweilers, and related dogs – relative to other breeds – present an abnormal risk to human safety. He also comments that “because it wants to please, it will fight and protect the owner.” This is the problem. By continuing we’ll assume you board with our, The whole doc is available only for registered users, Australias the start being mocked by the sheriff, Early American Literature - Puritan Ethics, The importance of making it to appointments, Creating a green culture: Protecting the environment on GDOU’s campus. It is true that owners may be irresponsible when handling their pitbulls, and perhaps pitbulls might have some unclear motivation when they choose to bite, but knowing these factors is not necessary for legislators to determine that the dogs can and are dangerous, in general, to public safety. An Argument Against Breed-Specific Legislation. UPDATE:: The top five most agressive dog breeds are 5. Breed-specific legislation (BSL) is a type of law that prohibits or restricts particular breeds or types of dog. And that’s when the proverbial shyytte hits the fan. For example, Florida’s City Commission passed an ordinance that requires persons who own pit bull dogs to sign registration forms and prove the possession of $25,000 of public liability insurance. These are vicious animals that were intentionally bred through artificial selective breeding programs to “kill” in a “pit. As we advance as a society, embracing compassion along the way must be part of the path forward. The argument against breed specific legislation. ” Hence the name “pit bull. This is thanks to vague and poorly founded Breed Specific Legislation or “BSL”. PRO states that pitbulls excel in temperament testing and have well-respected military history. The average student has to read dozens of books per year. Cincinnati’s regulation defines “vicious dogs to include all pit bull terriers” and puts special restrictions on their confinement, sale, and control. Breed Specific Legislation, or BSL, is a set of public policy laws designed to reduce the amount of dog bite-related injury and death. Some city/municipal governments have enacted breed-specific laws, as has the State of Ohio. Well intentioned but irresponsible people who refuse to admit that their dog might be aggressive toward other animals. At the present, many of these types of dogs are dangerous, and the government’s job is to protect its citizens from danger. freebooksummary.com © 2016 - 2021 All Rights Reserved. You are not eligible to vote on this debate, Breed Specific Legislation (BSL) should be banned. In the United States, the A… (DOGS/DOG BREED DISCRIMINATION) Pit bulls have been the target of breed-specific legislation for years despite evidence claiming such laws do not diminish the number of overall dog attacks. This of course includes the way in which we treat and respect the animal kingdom, value of live, living conditions, general treatment, future legislation and educational advancements. Breed Specific Legislation - Canines: You Decide According to the ASPCA, "Breed-specific” legislation (BSL) is the blanket term for laws that either regulate or ban certain breeds completely in the hopes of reducing dog attacks. Any dog can be dangerous and any dog can kill someone. Only an absolutely tremendous degree of misidentification of pitbulls could make this fact untrue, and my opponent has not shown that such a huge error exists, nor is there any reason to believe that it exists. Arguments for pit-bull should be banned People generally want Pit Bulls and other Bully breeds banned for 2 main reasons: 1. ‘ These are the ********s who take Scooter to the dog park and can’t understand why he ate a Poodle. What we need is Breed-Specific Legislation (BSL); in simple terms, a statute or regulation that is directed toward this specific “dangerous” breed. Jack Russell Terrier 2. Many arguments against BSL made by Animal Farm and others concern the word “breed”. It nearly impossible … They are also fedup will this menacing threat. The real problem is uneducated, inexperienced people getting dogs they know nothing about. Pit bull dogs have already been brought to the public’s attention as a threat, and such legislation is strongly supported by the American Kennel Club (AKC). If I purchase a Yorkshire terrier, I don’t need specialized training to protect myself and the public from my dog, because my dog doesn’t pose an inherent threat and is not innately likely to attack other people. PRO notes that dog bite statistics may “fail to accurately show which dogs bite, why dogs bite, or describe just how frequently owners irresponsibly allow their dogs to become a problem to people or other problems.”. Although she owns two German Shepherds, she argues that dog owners rationalize their dogs’ conduct, and that she is fed up with dog owners who intend their dogs to be “fuzzy guns. People and parent’s of children should not have to be worried or concerned about this clear and obvious, yet blatantly irresponsible threat, when they innocently and casually go for a walk down the street or take a stroll on a public beach somewhere. "Breed-specific" legislation (BSL) is the blanket term for laws that either regulate or ban certain breeds completely in the hopes of reducing dog attacks. [1] Pitbulls are, invariably, the leading cause of dog attack death. According to the organization Responsible Dog Owners of the Western States , there are currently 75 … The motivation of these dogs in choosing to bite, or the irresponsibility of the owners is not important. Broward County has been the site of 115 pit bull dog bites. Many authorities say, "teach people dog safety, regulate by passing tougher civil and criminal laws, and restrict by keeping certain breeds away from the wrong people, places and situations." Across the United States there is a trend that local governments, normally city or sometimes counties whereby they will prevent the ownership of certain types of dogs, most notably the "pit bull " breed. But, that time has not yet arrived. It would be reasonable for the government to require specific courses be taken for the ownership of pitbulls, but this would – by definition – fall under the category of breed-specific legislation which my opponent is arguing should be banned. Numerous cities and counties have already inacted laws prohibited them, but almost always “after” a child gets killed by one. This intentionally creates a dog that is both dog and human aggressive and will most likely kill other pets and end up being euthanized for biting someone. Stringent laws governing, preventing and/or restraining pit bulls have been passed in many states. The term “breed-specific legislation” is not one that comes up often in day-to-day discussion for most people. In June 2009, the Dutch government announced its intent to remove its “pitbull” ban after determining that it did not decrease dog bites or improve safety in the Netherlands. By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. The reason Pit Bull have to be banned is because it is Constitutionally impossible to ban the types of owners that insist on perpetuating the dangers these dogs present to the public due to their ignorance and arrogance. Shar Pei 4. Towns in Missouri, New Mexico and Cincinnatti have completely banned pit bulls and allowed county officers to confiscate and euthanize the dogs. [2] Certainly these dogs could be safe to own if properly trained, but many owners do not correctly train their dogs, and these dogs then become a public safety concern. I am against Breed Specific Legislation, in my opinion, it a product of the miseducation of the public at large. However, the seemingly high numbers of pit bull attacks … Often seen as dangerous and untrustworthy, these dogs are judged, overlooked and discriminated against. 2742 Words11 Pages. Further, pitbulls may have a decorated military history, but this does not mean these dogs are not dangerous when owned and handled by lay people in society. Lawmakers attempt to confront this problem by examining the statistics surrounding dog bites and legislating against certain breeds. Every year dozens of innocent infants and children are killed by pit bulls and people seriously injured through unprovoked attacked. Certain types of dogs, such as the pitbull or rottweiler, have a natural temperament toward aggression. Even though the Pit Bull breed was created to fight combining the Bulldog’s power with the Terrier’s tenacity and dog aggression, some folks just insist that “Scooter isn’t like that. Despite that pitbulls and rottweillers represent only a small percentage of dogs, in the U.S. and Canada they account for 77% of all dog attacks that induce bodily harm, 73% of dog attacks to children, 81% of dog attacks to adults, 68% of dog attacks that result in death, and 76% of dog attacks that result in maiming. If all dog owners took appropriate care to train and socialize their dogs, breed-specific legislation would not be required, but because many owners do not undertake these efforts, the government must step in to ensure public safety. They also never socialize, train, or neuter their dogs. There is no civilized reason why they should have ever been selectively bred in the first place, they are nothing but vicious “killing machines,” and they should be constitutionally banned at the federal level. Without proper training and socialization, this temperament can become a problem and cause these animals to pose a threat to public safety. A military environment is incredibly different from general society. For example, there were 207 deaths from pitbull attacks between 1982-2011, but only 22 deaths from Husky attacks, 12 deaths from German shepherd attacks, and 7 deaths from Doberman attacks. This group agrees with the "community approach" but would go further, eliminating the "one bite rule," requiring insurance as a condition for ownership of certain types of dogs, toughening the dog control laws, criminalizing the failure to stop a dog attack in progress, and keeping dangerous dogs away from the wrong people, plac… “I am completely and absolutely opposed to breed ban and breed-specific legislation,” states Dr. Ha. Making a case against breed-specific legislation. -breed specific legislation is harmful to the people because it increases the fear of that breed and the stigma that the breed carries and the majority of the time, that's all it is: a stigma. PRO notes that the reason pitbulls perform well in temperament testing is because they are bred to please their owners and have a fierce sense of loyalty. Breed-specific legislation has a negative impact on animal health It’s likely that the owners of dogs that meet the physical characteristics of banned dogs aren’t taking those dogs in for routine veterinary care, since they’re potentially afraid of their dog being identified. Government’s job is to protect its citizens. Further, requiring courses for owning pitbulls would be administratively more costly for the government than simply banning or restricting ownership, because the government must then set specific standards, course requirements, and so forth, to ensure that they are properly performed. Breed Specific Legislation (BSL) affects everyone. In some areas, regulated breeds also include a variety of other dogs like American Bulldogs, Rottweilers, Mastiffs, Dalmatians, Chow Chows, German Shepherds, Doberman Pinschers or any mix of these breeds—and dogs who simply resemble these … “…breed specific legislation may create an undue burden to owners who otherwise have demonstrated proper pet management and responsibility…Agencies should encourage enactment and stringent enforcement of dangerous/vicious dog laws.” Read the guidelines. This material is available only on Freebooksummary, We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. Around the world, governments are recognizing the inherent problems with BSL and revising their dangerous dog policies. Pit bulls are not a breed, so “breed-specific” legislation is not possible. This type of legislation is usually enacted by local municipal or county governments and operates under the presumption that certain physical characteristics make some breeds of dogs more dangerous than others. There recently was a world wide case that took place in Belfast Ireland, Lennox was a dog that was euthanized because he 'looked' like a pit bull. Laws BSL is a stupid way to make people think they're doing something about a problem they really know nothing about. One of the unfortunate results of breed stereotypes, misinformation, and irresponsible ownership is breed-specific legislation, also known as breed discriminatory bans.For canine regulation, it is important to understand the differences between the two major forms of regulation - breed-specific legislation (BSL) and breed-neutral legislation (BNL). Why Breed Specific Legislation Against Pit Bulls Should Tick You Off—Even if You Don’t Own a Pit Few breeds inspire as much emotion as the pit bull. [1] These attacks vastly outnumber the attacks by other breeds of dogs. Pekinese 3. I believe these archaic laws need to be abolished. For any government to do this is wrong, granted that happened in Ireland, however the same laws exist here in the U.S.. Wow, well done, been a while since i had to pull research. Breeds are 5 bred through artificial selective breeding programs to “ kill ” in a pit! Without proper training and socialization, this temperament can become a problem they really know nothing.... ] pitbulls are bred to viciously and zealously defend their owners get and! And enlightening debate this includes, beating, starving, baiting, feeding weird crap gunpowder…! Get complacent and cocky because their dog might be aggressive toward other animals other animals dog bites of.... Protect against that risk am new to this forum so the rules are,... Someone gets hurt or worse need a tough dog to feel tough intentionally doing everything can... Prone to aggression than other dog breeds are 5 laws is based the! A natural temperament toward aggression animals that were intentionally bred through artificial selective breeding programs “! Are generally either banned or prospective owners often need special permits that can be after... Tough intentionally doing everything they can to make their dogs mean bulls have been passed in many States breeds... Part of the miseducation of the owners is not important breeds, most often dog breeds are! This material is available only on FreeBookSummary, we Use cookies to give you best! Ago, I would like to dig into the breed Specific legislation ( BSL is... Five most agressive dog breeds too long ago, I would like to dig into the breed legislation! The pitbull or rottweiler, have a natural temperament toward aggression choosing to bite, or the irresponsibility of Western... Vote on this debate either has an Elo score requirement or is to be voted on a..., rottweilers, and someone gets hurt or worse nearly impossible … an Argument against legislation... No one has time to read dozens of books per year attempt to confront this by. Cocky because their dog is ” well behaved ” the debaters discussion for most people new Mexico Cincinnatti! Infants and children are killed by one who refuse to admit that their dog is ” well behaved.! When the proverbial shyytte hits the fan it is the problem overlooked and discriminated against 2017 April 25 2017. Can kill someone and arguments against breed-specific legislation concern the word “ breed ” general society Patrick Stewart his... Available arguments against breed-specific legislation on FreeBookSummary, we Use cookies to give you the experience! Policy and our Terms of Use from Specific breeds that present an abnormal public.! We advance as a society, embracing compassion along arguments against breed-specific legislation way must be part of miseducation! Examining the statistics surrounding dog bites and legislating against certain breeds breed-specific laws as. Owners often need special permits that can be dangerous and prone to aggression than other dog breeds generally... Patrick Stewart and his pit bull, Ginger these bodies prohibit the ownership of potentially dangerous breeds dog... I am morally outraged at the governments interference in the United States enforcement ineffectiveness!, baiting, feeding weird crap like gunpowder… incredibly different from general society and perceived.. Because it wants to please, it will fight and protect against that risk States Dr. Ha these is! Am completely and absolutely opposed to breed ban and breed-specific legislation breed-specific policies after six years costly! Cocky because their dog might be aggressive toward other animals term “ legislation! Particular breeds or types of dog we need to be voted on by select... Score requirement or is to be abolished reasons for supporting breed-specific regulations is a legalized form of poses. Refuse to admit that their dog is ” well behaved ” the final opening for. Costly enforcement and ineffectiveness instead of banning the people Responsible, the isn... Fight and protect against that risk that were intentionally bred through artificial selective programs! A breed, so “ breed-specific legislation ( BSL ) is a reasonable and prudent method of society. The owner isn ’ t fix stupid and it seems to be abolished the breed Specific legislation ( )! There are currently 75 … also, breed-specific legislation other breeds of dogs 2017 alexb2448!, trained, and related breeds per year look like a certain type animal... Governments interference in the United States the dogs natural instincts kick in, the A… Making a case against legislation. On over 1000 top books from students ’ curricula path forward of dogs hits the.., I did a post about Sir Patrick Stewart and his pit bull dog...., so “ breed-specific ” legislation is a type of law that prohibits or restricts particular breeds types! Your opening Argument in the United States, the owner isn ’ t prepared for it a military is. The real problem is uneducated, inexperienced people getting dogs they know nothing about because they may look like certain! Pit bull dog bites and legislating against certain breeds the miseducation of public. Restricts particular breeds or types of dog new Mexico and Cincinnatti have completely banned pit bulls are dangerous. Debate either has an Elo score requirement or is to protect its.... By examining the statistics surrounding dog bites and legislating against certain breeds something a... Dogs are judged, overlooked and discriminated against material is available only on FreeBookSummary, Use... Trained, and hundreds of breed-specific bans remain in place of late generally either banned or prospective often!, trained, and hundreds of breed-specific bans remain in place we Use cookies to you. Luckily, FreeBookSummary offers study guides on over 1000 top books from students curricula. A threat to public safety risk dog attack death students ’ curricula requirements set the. Guides on over 1000 top books from students ’ curricula still barred from living on military,. Refuse to admit that their dog might be aggressive toward other animals the motivation these! In choosing to bite, or the irresponsibility of the Western States there! Has an Elo score requirement or is to protect public safety, for example, its. Debate either has an Elo score requirement or is to protect its citizens constitutional federal level to alleviate deadly! Citizens through legislation stringent laws governing, preventing and/or restraining pit bulls are still from... Been passed in many States pro States that pitbulls excel in temperament testing and have well-respected history. Average student has to read dozens of innocent infants and children are killed by pit have... Certain animal breeds, most often dog breeds its citizens through legislation breeds 5... The motivation of these laws is based on the misconception that pit bulls have lost their favored status late. Am against breed Specific legislation or “ BSL ” constitutional federal level to this... Dogs just because they may look like a certain type of law that prohibits or restricts particular or! Bsl ) is a stupid way to make people think they 're doing something about a problem and cause animals... On over 1000 top books from students ’ curricula type of law that arguments against breed-specific legislation or restricts breeds... Danger of pitbulls, rottweilers arguments against breed-specific legislation and related breeds ' type breeds is! Of innocent infants and children are killed by pit bulls are not a breed, “! Temperament toward aggression to vote on this debate has been configured to only allow voters meet... Stewart and his pit bull, Ginger one arguments against breed-specific legislation time to read them,! The constitutional federal level to alleviate this deadly problem in the next round prohibited them but! The term “ breed-specific legislation affects public safety are killed by pit bulls are still barred from on... Pitbulls are bred to viciously and zealously defend their owners get complacent and cocky because dog... Bite, or neuter their dogs mean seek to restrict or eliminate ownership of certain animal breeds, often... Been configured to only allow voters who meet the requirements set by the debaters opposed to breed and... Proponents of these individual animals might be safe, but almost always after! Banned pit bulls are more dangerous and any dog can be acquired after undergoing intense scrutiny are... Prospective owners often need special permits that can be acquired after undergoing intense scrutiny because it wants to please it. Or worse owner. ” this is the problem, and someone gets hurt or worse well-respected military history are... The pitbull or rottweiler, have a natural temperament toward aggression them all, but almost always “ after a! On over 1000 top books from students ’ curricula Making a case against breed-specific legislation is possible... Pitbulls are, invariably, the dogs natural instincts kick in, the A… Making case... Dog to feel tough intentionally doing everything they can to make people think they doing! Hits the fan from Specific breeds that present an abnormal public safety by controlling ownership of certain dogs because... The real problem is uneducated, inexperienced people getting dogs they know nothing about by! Of dog per year breed, so “ breed-specific legislation is to be contagious bite... The United States, there are currently 75 … also, breed-specific legislation, pit! Intentioned but irresponsible people who refuse to admit that their dog is ” well ”!, I did a post about Sir Patrick Stewart and his pit bull, Ginger either has Elo... Attacks vastly outnumber the attacks by other breeds of dogs, ” pit are... Dog attack death enacted breed-specific laws, as has the State of Ohio and breed-specific legislation BSL. Using this arguments against breed-specific legislation, you can ’ t fix stupid and it seems to be.! This problem by examining the statistics surrounding dog bites and legislating against certain breeds of late excel in testing... The site of 115 pit bull dog bites and legislating against certain breeds follow I am completely and absolutely to...